Showing posts with label Genre: Romance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Genre: Romance. Show all posts

Tuesday, 10 September 2013

Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu

Wow. Just wow.

I don’t think my opinion of an anime has ever changed so drastically within the space of a few episodes. Wow…

In the beginning I had high hopes for Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu. The concept alone was pretty interesting and with the right development could have been a compelling taken on school streaming and to a certain extent classism. The primary plot concerns the ranking of students by their academic ability into A-F sets, something commonplace in the UK, but apparently rare in Japan. Not that the lower sets receive additional support or supervision mind, just substantially less privileges. In the case of the bottom set, Class F, a run-down classroom, complete with old broken furniture (desks that later get replaced with cardboard boxes) and broken windows. Cos those conditions will really motivate students!  So, the students of Class F (all six of them) decide their going to challenge the system and “declare war” on the other sets. Honestly, I really like this pitch. If it had had an ounce more of thought or if it had followed actually through with this set up, then I would probably be singing a different tune right about now.

So, episode one, Class F declare war on Class E. And its goofy and silly and over the top, and they win. Huzzah! In episode two, a shocking twist of events, Class A declares war on Class F, and Class F lose! Oh well, didn’t expect them to complete their task by the second episode! And that that’s for eight straight episodes… I am dead serious. Apparently there’s a rule that the losing set cannot declare war for three months, so the main plot pretty much stops. Instead fuck all happens for eight episodes. Eight inane, grating episodes. Presumably this is supposed to pass for character development, but it’s so fucking derivative. There’s even a god-damn pool episode! This has fuck all to do with anything.

Onto the characters, they range from tolerable to fucking diabolical. The main character is a perpetual child and screeching moron. The love-interests are so underwhelming, and the fucking ninja-pervert….please die. Most of the jokes fall flat because they are the same one note repeated at nausea. Girl has flat chest, guy looks like girl, everyone has their own stalker, ninja-pervert takes a panty shot, and it’s a non-stop laugh riot! For all of five minutes. The fact remains that we’ve seen this format before and done better. And it wasn’t all that funny then either. The problem is that the characters are not invested. We as the audience are supposed to root for these characters, because they are the underdogs, because the system is unfair, and because they are treated badly. But that’s rarely shown because that is not what interests the writers. The protagonists are not crusading for equality. They just want the entitlements awarded to the higher sets. Without any of the work. They not only support the system, they want to benefit from it. And frankly, that’s not something I can get behind.

So… yeah I didn’t much enjoy this one.

Rating: 4/10


Monday, 23 April 2012

Hana Saku Iroha - Review


Hana Saku Iroha was somewhat of a bumpy ride, producing varying reactions along the way. In the end it had a wonderfully well written arc that result in a solid and satisfying climax that shined over prior calamities. I think the main problem was that it was good at what it promised, a slice of life, coming of age, the daily on-goings of a traditional Japanese Inn and appallingly bad at the unexpected – the outlandish comedy and romance triangle.  In both these areas characters and situations didn’t feel natural and interrupted the general flow – for example the perverted writer who writes explicit porn involving the underage girls at the inn, when discovered he kidnaps Ohana and later attempts suicide. Giving him a job at the inn is obvious the workings of a rational, sane mind. Yet this character becomes the perverted comic relief for the remaining series. Despite the fact I can’t imagine any teenage girl finding this situation comfortable. 

As for the romance section, the Minko-Trohu-Ohana triangle is expectedly, but even so the latter part appears almost out of nowhere. It certainly doesn’t come across as a genuine love interest, more or less like a plot device to create tension between Minko and Ohana. It does serve one good purpose, with Minko unjustly on the war path with Ohana; the ever-annoying Ohana is given a sympathetic light and thus becomes more endearing. As for Ohana, the primary protagonist the series did a fantastic job overall of making an overtly optimistic teenager, likable and compelling. In context this is a girl who quite literally has her life turned upside down and placed into a familiar environment, but what makes her relatable is the moment she begins to challenge her mother in favour of the inn. This is when Ohana stops being the archetypal heroine and becomes an average teenager.


 Rating: 7/10 

Friday, 1 April 2011

Kimi ni Todoke 2 Review


The second season of Kimi ni Todoke (From Me to You/Reaching You, depending on translation) is approximately half the length but definitely twice as comprehensive. Rather than another seemingly endless saga supposedly will they/won’t they but more accurately ‘do they even have feelings for each other?’, Kimi ni Todoke 2 sets itself a clear direction, to resolve the main romance in a timely fashion.

With this task in mind, the show was able develop the main characters much more thoroughly, in particular Kazehaya, who came across as far less wooden this time around. The inclusion of a rival for Sawako’s affections seemed to work wonders, almost shaking Kazehaya into a reaction, but ultimately clarifying his position beyond simple friendship, something which the first season was slightly ambiguous towards. Now the only obstacle standing between Sawako and Kazehaya are quite literally themselves and their perpetual refuse to address their feelings. Of course a constant string of misunderstandings doesn’t help matters. This approach requires as much patience as its predecessor. Even so, it’s much more worthwhile since it recognises that relationships are gradual and often confusing, outright rejecting the overused love-at-first-sight concept.

That being said, Kimi ni Todoke is nothing neither new nor imaginative. It is simply an in depth exploration of two well rounded teenagers who will inevitably fall in love. It may not be novel, but it’s certainly focused, which again is a step up from season one. Presumably this is why this season went with twelve episodes over twenty-five, a much more compact and on target run, without being clogged down by useless filler. The show does provide a nice view of everyday school life, emphasising study groups, after school gatherings and celebrating festivals. It’s quaint, enjoyable and nicely animated, summing the anime up as a whole. Without a doubt the sequel is a wonderful improvement.

Rating: 7/10

Monday, 28 March 2011

Dragon Crisis! Review

As far as light-hearted, romantic-harems go, Dragon Crisis doesn’t set out to achieve more then it physically does. What do I mean by that? Simply put, priority has been placed on producing as much pre-teen sickly sweetness as possible, rather than attempting expand the already overpopulate genre in terms of depth and innovation. Dragon Crisis doesn’t pretend to be anything more than a sit-back-and-switch-off show. At least it’s honest.

Dragon Crisis opens with a classic, the magical-girl-in-a-suitcase scenario, a red dragon named Rose. Rose appears to know Ryuji and is fanatical about him, shifting the plot focus onto the antics of living with a girl-dragon with the mind of a two year old. Sure it’s funny but it completely bypasses giving a credible explanation for why Rose was in the suitcase to begin with. From start to finish Dragon Crisis prefers to distract the audience with the big picture, the Ryuji and Rose affair, rather then taking the time to fill in the small but gapping plot holes. This half-arsed approach prevents it from excelling.

There is one main arc to open and close the show, featuring the one and only major villain, whose actual motive seems particularly disincentive, not to mention a tad clichéd. Other then being required to as the primary antagonist and for the sake of the plot, there is no real reason for him to be interested in Rose. If Onyx knows something about red dragons we don’t, isn’t the finale the place to say it? Unfortunately most characters also suffer from acting out of convenience rather then of their own accord. Unsurprisingly this is a commonplace problem when you try to shoehorn a formula.

The middle consists of several sub-stories, primarily to connect another magical girl into Ryuji’s life. This introduction process starts to become tiresome pretty quickly, considering most characters tend to resort to the same tactic of attacking Ryuji first, asking questions second. The show is almost incapable of progressing without (literally) dropping a magical girl into our laps. In a sense there is no real commitment, just a series of half-hearted attempts to expand the cast and ultimately Ryuji’s harem. This is just sloppy storytelling, pure and simple.

In addition, the fact that Ryuji even has a harem gets increasingly difficult to swallow. As the leading male, in theory there should be plenty of room for him to grow as a person. Initially Ryuji is blander then a beige dishtowel and somehow manages to maintain the same level of dullness throughout the show. The only female fancy that feels halfway believable is that of equally drippy classmate, Misaki, but even this crush feels staged when Misaki recalls her first encounter with Ryuji and most treasured memory. While an explanation is later given for Ryuji ‘magnetic’ personality, it seems to cover dragons but not humans nor the wolf girl, so it’s hardly concrete. Interestingly this concept is actually quite appealing, but frustratingly before it’s even given a chance to develop, it’s immediately rejected in the next episode. The writing on this show is such a big flop.

Obviously the main romantic couple are Ryuji and Rose, despite having zero chemistry. For a large portion of the show, their relationship appears entirely one sided, while Ryuji appears to humour Rose and her constant declarations of love, yet regarding them with some embarrassment. Although a male teenager, Ryuji is unduly chaste, never showing romantic interest in any of the growing number of girls flocking towards him. Until the finale that is, when the plot needs him to man up and kiss Rose. Honestly the entire show has been so formatted that even the inevitable couple feels clinical and contrived.

Dragon Crisis is enjoyable, especially if you like light-hearted, fluffy anime that ultimately doesn’t go anywhere. Its fun, it’s bright and it’s cheerful, so there is potential to be easily drawn in. However the overall premise suffers from lack of sufficient thought, planning and of course, creativity. This is entirely a surface anime, what you see is entirely what you get – one long cliché. As long as you go in knowing this, you won’t be too disappointed.

Rating: 5/10

Wednesday, 9 March 2011

Skip Beat! Review


Skip Beat tells the story of Kyoko Mogami, a cheery 16 year old dropout, who leaves her small town and heads to Tokyo on the arm of the prince of her dreams, Shotaro Fuwa. While Sho focuses on becoming a famous pop idol, Kyoko struggles to hold down three part-time jobs in order to afford their accommodation and living expenses. Not that Kyoko minds of course, she is, after all, a typical shoujo heroine – obedient, self sacrificing and completely besotted with her love interest. Sho, on the other hand, fails to show even the slightest gratitude or even respect Kyoko as a fellow human being. It’s blatantly clear that Sho regards Kyoko as little more than a servant and Kyoko laps it up every second. Initially Kyoko fits into the kind of anime girl I absolutely detest. And then something wonderful happens…

Once Kyoko overhears the truth, or rather it is painstakingly spelt out to her, a rapid transformation takes place. The weak, boring, doormat archetype becomes a hostile, fiery red-head, hell bent on revenge by becoming an idol herself. The premise itself might seem a little far fetched, but it does take into the context the situation and the characters themselves. After all how does a nobody take on an egotistical superstar? By beating them at their own game, of course!

Not that Kyoko has an easy time of breaking into the industry, she has no real talent to speak of, she lacks essential characteristics namely the ability to be loved, her insane rampages do more harm then good and she is pretty much looked down upon by everyone. Nevertheless people are drawn to Kyoko, her straight talking, persistent yet honest nature enables her to stand out, she has something which makes her likeable, and isn’t that how show business ultimately works? In all, personality and being memorable seems to work in Kyoko’s favour and she is given the opportunity to work her way into the agency.

Skip Beat is far more then a mere nobody-to-idol series, it’s a personal journey of self discovery. Kyoko soon realises that she has spent her entire life being groomed by Sho’s parents to become his wife and run their inn. She acknowledges that because of Sho’s interest in her, she never had any real female friends. And even that she would like to be an ordinary high school girl. As the series continues, Kyoko sheds her past, becoming a stronger and more attractive character, her primary motivation for acting is no longer simple vengeance, through Kyoko still dislikes Sho, he is no longer her sole driving force. Kinda relieving actually, it’s good that Kyoko is able to break free from Sho’s total control, even turn the tables a little, rather then remain dependant upon her hatred for Sho. It’s progressive and powerful, yet so very simple.

Despite a relatively good build up, Skip Beat is unable to deliver a satisfactory ending. It just ends, nothing more. It’s highly probable the creators intended to continue the series with a second season, sometimes these things take a while, or sometimes for reasons beyond our control, they simply don’t happen. Too bad. A romantic triangle between Kyoko, Sho and Ren was on the pangs of blossoming but with no real resolution, it makes the entire series feel left wide open. Aside from this, Skip Beat is a truly refreshing show; it takes utterly no time to get into and to fall in love with.

Rating: 8.5/10

Friday, 4 February 2011

First Impressions: Dragon Crisis!

Dragon Crisis!

Cute dragon girl has whiny teenage boy fixation!


I should have reviewed this one long before now, my bad. Or rather it’s the anime’s bad. Dragon Crisis is just dumb. It’s a clichéd hand-me-down series, absolutely no thinking required. Yet, I kinda like it, especially after episode three (no spoilers). Dragon Crisis doesn’t pretend to be any more then it is, light hearted and fun. As for the characters themselves, they vary. Ryuji is your standard, generic, angst ridden tween with two girls digging him (don’t ask me why), Rose is perfectly adorable and annoyingly obsessed kid sisterish rolled into one fire breather. While cousin Eriko seems to be plugging the fan service element of the show. In all, the plot hangs very loosely amongst terms “breaker/brokers”, “lost precious” with very little substance and gapping plot holes such as why Rose was hiding in a suitcase to begin with. Hopefully the anime can be executed neatly and even rise above its initial impression.

6/10

Friday, 7 January 2011

Otome Youkai Zakuro - Review


Some animes are so perfectly charming that it can make finding fault difficult, a mere challenge in most cases, yet Otome Youkai Zakuro (Demon Maiden Zakuro) seems to have emerged unscathed. The only real criticism I can provide is that the series doesn't expand upon the half-spirit element into an entirely new dimension, then again, I'm not convinced this is necessarily a bad thing. The shows foundations are solid, the story is thoroughly engaging and the lead characters are all amiable. If its not broken, don't fix it. In a nutshell.

Set during the Meiji era of an alternative reality Japan, where humans and spirits coexist, the newly formed Ministry of Spirits Affairs is devised to deal with subsequence clashes between the two. Officers Agemaki, Riken and Ganryu are partnered with half-spirit girls, Zakuro, Susukihotaru, and twins Bonbori and Hozuki respectively. Primary protagonists Zakuro and Agemaki's partnership soaks up most of the limelight, as the pair progress through stages of initial dislike/distrust to understanding and friendship. In hindsight their relationship seems the most healthy, especially when compared to the laid out on a plate romances of the other couples.

The main story arc turns up quite quickly, blending smoothly in between the numerous filler plots and background stories of the main characters that allow for some splendid and detailed growth before leading to an almost natural conclusion. From beginning to end, the simple charm of Otome Youkai Zakuro is the shows strongest allure and rightfully so. I've been bewitched and I guarantee you will be too!

Rating: 8.5/10

Sunday, 2 January 2011

Kimi ni Todoke Review


In anticipation of the upcoming live action featuring Miura Haruma (Bloody Monday/Gokusen 3) as the male lead, I decided to sit down and watch the original anime. Typically I'm not a fan of romantic comedies especially concerning a teenage cast, they tend to be consistently monotonous. Boy meets girl, despite having little to no chemistry they fall in love and spend a sluggish amount of time getting together. The old 'will they/won't they?' chestnut gets frustratingly drawn out during a course of illogical events and irrational actions. In essence Kimi Ni Todoke (From Me to You) is more interesting then it should be, since it doesn't deviate from what is expected.

The story focuses on heroine Sawako, a introverted loner, cruelly nicknamed Sadako "the girl from the Ring" as tediously pointed out over and over again, a seemingly laughable premise, until we learn how her shyness is construed as gloom by her classmates, leading to her social exclusion. Though this actually renders the character as identifiable and we are quickly able to regard her with fondness. Howbeit the tendency for Sawako's personality to go overboard is all too frequent, she is often portrayed as too innocent, too native and ultimately too nice, especially when compared to the average fifteen year old girl. Still, Sawako is likeable, which is the main thing.

Enter the love interest, popular heartthrob Kazehaya, who starts paying Sawako attention. Problem is, there is no logical reason for him to do so. Its a minor plot hole, but one commonplace in romantic comedies. Kazehaya encourages Sawako to communicate her feelings in order to make friends just because he is [i]that[/i] nice a guy, seems far fetched. Rather Kazehaya behaves according to how the plot needs him too in order to move along. On top of that, Kazehaya doesn't come across as particularly interested, genuinely a nice guy, but that's about it. I have no clue why other girls want him so badly other than it accommodates the plot.

The enviable Sawado/Kazehaya hook up drags on for 25 long episodes, which *spoiler* doesn't happen. Its slightly disappointing that they don't as much as kiss in those last fleeting moments, the progression of their relationship is so slow that I'd be surprise if they are onto holding hands by the middle of season two. However the series did capture the searing jealous and manipulative nature of the school girl crush quite nicely. Love rival Kurumei was delightfully wicked in her endeavours, crushing the competition in her single minded attempt to gain Kazehaya's affection. Its a shame this sub-plot wasn't carried on to the end of the series.

Still, I'm actually looking forward to season two.

6/10


Monday, 20 December 2010

Fortune Arterial 1-10


Its open season for vampires. Not in the classic Dracula/Hellsing/Blade badass archetypes of course, thanks to Meyer the rules on vampire mythology have been rewritten, now comprising of fluffy teenagers, who'd rather worry about organising school events then biting necks. Brother and sister Lori and Erika Sendo are your standard modern vamps, pretty, popular, zero aversion to sunlight, the works. Just be thankful they don't sparkle.

Despite introducing (and painfully explaining) the vampire subplot in the second episode, that minor detail seems forgotten to the point of being inconsequential during the following events. As the show attempts to warm the audience to its characters by showcasing day to day school events and the blossoming romance between Erika and Kohei Hasekura, clichés are kept at a distance. Until they make a sour point of returning.

Erika faces a dilemma, at the end of her high school year she must have bitten at least one human and made them her 'servant' - remains human but has supernatural powers and lasting life, or return home to Mummy dear and never see the light of day. Wow. Tough breaks [/sarcasm]. Of course Erika doesn't want to be a vampire, she wants to be human, which is why she actively denies herself blood, and I'll leave you to work out the consequences. So, the main problem I have with this storyline, is that I don't sympathize with Erika. At all. Presumably I'm suppose to, but honestly she just comes across as annoying. Ironically its not even Erika's fault. The show has fallen into the trap of presenting its vampires as perfect, so popular, so attractive, so good at school and sports, that the siblings are naturally idolized by their peers. What the average teens wishes they could be like. And all Erika has to do to maintain this is drink a couple of transfusions bags. Yet she doesn't want to. Because she is stubborn. Therefore annoying.

On top of that the premise has been done to death and much, much better. It lacks the broodiness of Vampire Knight or the comic charm of Karin/Chibi Vampire to be a really good romance. With the finale right around the corner, its doubtful the Fortune Arterial will be able to redeem itself. Not if the ending is as predictable as it seems. Erika bites Kohei. They live happily ever after. The end.

What a bore.