Showing posts with label Anime: Recommendation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anime: Recommendation. Show all posts

Monday, 21 May 2012

Mawaru Penguindrum - Review


There are animes, there are art forms and then there is Kunihiko Ikuhara, the director of iconic magical girl animes Sailor Moon and Revolutionary Girl Utena. Evidently Ikuhara is well versed in cookie-cutter shows as well as breath-taking breaking the mould shows. So you’ll either get exactly what you want or exactly what you didn’t expect. Nevertheless both Sailor Moon and Revolutionary Girl Utena deal with a similar platform (not to mention virtually identical animation); Mawaru Penguindrum takes a fresh and entirely different approach. The concept is a little hard to pin down as the genre(s) is less shojo-romance and more mystery/comedy/sci-fi. And there are penguins. Lots of penguins.

The series centres on three siblings, twins Shouma and Kanba and their terminally ill younger sister, Himari. Initially Himari dies but is immediately reanimated into a penguin princess during one of the most spectacular magical girl transformations I’ve ever witnessed. The new and improved Himari demands a penguindrum in exchange for their sister’s new found health. What is a penguindrum? The princess doesn’t say, nor do we really find out until the very last episode and even then it’s still a little ambiguous.

The characters are all first rate. It’s near impossible to dislike any of them. Shouma and Kanba serve as superb protagonists, challenged with the heart-wrenching task of trying to save a loved one, a task that eventually leads them apart and seeking conflicting paths. Himari appears cute as a button one moment, than high-and-mighty princess the next, both roles are electrifying. One potential problem is the incest, fortunately that is resolved in the most satisfying conclusion, it’s not incest (major spoilers). Even Ringo, who is principally introduced as an annoying, single-minded stalker, has such stark revelations about her past, that the character is renovated into someone relatable and ultimately likable.

Mawaru Penguindrum is very much a character study in the sense that all of the primary cast have a rough upbringing and are in some way scarred, allowing for plenty of growth and development. One minor setback of the traumatic childhood is the over use of the lonely/abandoned child complex. This leads to great effect in some situations, namely the horrendous child broiler scenes which really work to drive home that there is something underlying evil with this society and not so much in others, chiefly the Masako storyline. Despite what I said early, this is one character that we didn’t get to see utilized to her full potential. She and her brother Mario were mostly padding for a shocking plot twist. Interesting enough, but perhaps not quite on par with the rest of the cast.

The storyline is impeccably well-crafted. From the outset, this is set up to be a tragedy. The beginning is (naturally) deceptive as the light-hearted, whimsical romantic-comedy element is gradually lost and replaced with a much colder ascetic. Mawaru Penguindrum is also a masterpiece of symbolism and surrealism that will certainly require several views in order to soak up all the references. Clearly nothing has been left to chance, or fate as is more relevant.

Mawaru Penguindrum is nothing short of magnificent. The sheer level of depth, of detail that has gone into the shows meticulous design is quite frankly staggering and the outcome is simply flawless. The devotion of the siblings as the core motivator is pretty powerful and the ending is incredibly satisfactory if a little open ended. Kunihiko Ikuhara is a true visionary and hopefully this will be the shape of more things to come from this wonderfully talented director.

Rating: 9/10
Recommended. 

Sunday, 13 May 2012

Tiger and Bunny Review


The core concept behind Tiger and Bunny isn’t exactly new and/or original. The superhero as a celebrity aspect has been paraded around before, most notably in the Iron Man films. Tiger and Bunny simply takes this to the next conceivable consumer level, the superhero as a reality TV star. As a self-confessed marvel geek, this very notion is contradictory to what constitutes as a hero, which is a well-held running theme. What is so controversial about this premise is the notion that the superheroes fight crime in order to win brownie points as oppose to their personal sense of moral justice. In fact the only character that really maintains old skool hero values is our primary protagonist, Tiger which initially results in his low ranking and often become more of a hindrance.

The secondary protagonist, Bunny has a tragic backstory more in keeping with the classic superhero roots, pretty blatantly a Batman rip. Fortunately the writers have the good sense to spin a new angle and make the character mainly concerned with solving his parents’ murder as oppose to becoming a vigilante. However we don’t learn much about the other heroes and when we do it often exposes their all too human motivations, pressure from parents, wanting to stand out or in the case of Blue Rose, wanting to become a teen idol. In the long run it renders the characters human and flawed, which is not what heroes are supposed to represent. Yet by grounding them in a sense of reality, it actually gives them a greater depth rather than having them portrayed as saints taking on societies responsibilities just because they were born with super powers.

Having said that there are a few minor hiccups, the most notable is in regards to Tiger and his conflict as both superhero and single father. While it’s a nice twist to have a single father superhero, in this particular anime which re-writes the superhero genre, it’s never really explained why this division is necessary. Since his identity is kept secret and the rest of his immediate family already know, why hide it from his pre-teen daughter? Doesn’t he want her know? Wouldn’t that make his life easier? Wouldn’t she be more sympathetic with his absentee parenting? Or he could just quit and raise his child full time, which should actually take priority. In all it seems too contrived and too forced, not to mention almost out of context with the show.

What really intrigued me about this show was the collaboration between cultures. The notion of the superhero, the overt commercialization and especially the setting right down to the dollar currency system are grounded in western ideologies. Even the genesis of the superheroes has a lot in common with another popular American franchise, the X-Men. Yet later on when Tiger leaves to visit his daughter we’re transported to a rural Japanese backdrop. This element of harmony is made none the more clearer than between the two protagonists, Tiger is obviously Japanese and Bunny is western, presumably American. Interestingly there is a similar congruence with the futuristic technological advances whilst being set in 1978 (according to the Christmas clock). Overall this blend mingled well with the plot, adding an extra creative boost along the way.

As everyone should know, every good superhero requires a nemesis. While Tiger and Bunny did deliver a big bad towards the end of the series both with an unexpected twist and the potential for a much greater threat, this paled in comparison to the anti-hero, Lunatic. The character was introduced in small intervals allowing the audience to connect the dots while the protagonists remain blissfully unaware. It was almost a shame that Lunatic wasn’t utilized more.  Still, there is plenty of room for a follow up series and even talk of a movie.

Rating: 8.5/10


Thursday, 26 April 2012

Steins;Gate Review


In terms of plot, Steins; Gate is a remarkable accomplishment. It handles an interesting premise with an original and thought-provoking manner. As a time-travel-theory novice I can’t vouch for the accuracy of the physics involved, nevertheless the context is pretty heavy-going, enough to indicate the writers have a vague idea over the subject matter. Or at least enough to make the utterly absurd sound plausible i.e. the microwave that sends text messages to the past. Unfortunately this is one of the few drawbacks, the overtly technical side. Understandably it can be a bit overwhelming especially in the beginning and factoring in the speed at which things progress, it’s not easy to digest initially. 

Steins; Gate takes it time to introduce the cast, the setting and the science, all done to the anime’s credit, before plummeting full throttle into a magnificent thriller that becomes the focal point. Despite a relatively repetitive sequence of events (literally), the storyline itself does not become repetitive. Quite the opposite actually, it becomes grippingly addictive. This is in no small part due to the unravelling of the complex, multi-layered plot and the fascinating exploration of trying to twist it back together.

For the most part, the characters are crafted wonderfully. Okarin as the primary protagonist and self-proclaimed mad scientist experiences the most character development largely down to the emotional roller-coaster he endures and thus is the most three dimensional. Whereas his immediate companions, Mayuri and Daru are essentially stereotypes or stereotypes, yet are delightful enough. Kurisu the female protagonist and blatant love interest is a little more challenging. On the one hand her interactions with Okarin provide enjoyable conflict and on the other her personality weakens in the context of the backstory. However it’s the secondary cast, cat-girl and the girl-guy who are an eternal source of annoyance. At first I took them for throw away characters and I wasn’t strictly speaking wrong. As plot devices they’re integral, as characters they’re not.

All in all, Steins; Gate is an incredible feat, one that’s rarely seen these days. Yes, it’s not perfect, there are flaws primarily in the character department, but these are so minimal in comparison to the shows ultimate triumph, it practically re-writes the sci-fi genre. High recommendations.

Rating: 9/10

Wednesday, 6 July 2011

Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae o Boku-Tachi wa Mada Shiranai Review



Animes like We Still Don’t Know the Name of the Flower We Saw That Day, neatly nicknamed Anohana for short, are rare to come by. Wrapping up this month after a mere eleven perennial episodes, Anohana is fairly short but definitely sweet, remaining on the mark for the entirely of its run. It was smooth sailing for the most part with a couple of hiccups along the way, in particular the melodramatic minor characters, however strong planning and execution gave the show a greater purpose, more compelling then the sum of its parts.


The storyline focused on the complex relationship between five childhood friends who have drifted apart three years prior after the death of their sixth member, Meiko ‘Menma’ Honma. The primary protagonist, Jinta ‘Jintan’ Yadomi, the group’s former leader, now social recluse, is the only person able to see or communicate with Menma of whom he initially dismisses as a hallucination, a manifestation of his guilt. The relationship between Jintan and ghost girl Menma is both moe-humorous and deeply troubled at the same time, as Jintan struggles to come to terms with the supernatural return of his former friend. In essence Anohana is a coming-of-age drama, which has its characters enthralled with typical teenage dilemmas such as unrequited crushes, depleting friendship circles and social alienation, all the while having to deal with significant childhood trauma.


Anohana not only crafts great chemistry between Jintan and Menma, but also amongst the other four side characters, Anaru, Tsuruko, Yukiatsu and Poppo. The characterization is nothing short of wonderful, each teenager depiction is detailed and trendsetting, while primarily consisting of angst-ridden teenagers, and none come across as annoying, whiny or vastly unlikable. I’m almost impressed. This has to be a first. A primary strength of Anohana is that each character faces their own brand of grief which transpires into very different reactions. It explores the many ways that grief can be felt or expressed through physical escapism, falling in with the wrong crowd to irrational feelings of jealousy and resentment.


Nevertheless this tactic is not without its flaws. Whereas some characters are subtle and realistic in their anguish, others are overplayed. None more so then cross-dressing Yukiatsu, who’s youthful love for Menma drives him to impersonate her, white dress and all. You’ve seriously got to question how sincerely a child can not only comprehend an intricate emotion such as love but also hold a flame indisputably for three years. On the other hand Tsuruko was severely downplayed, while she remained the most ‘together’ member of the group, I couldn’t help but find her primary reason – the unreciprocated crush aspect, rather disappointing since it was already relevant to Anaru.


As a whole Anohana is a fine example of how well simplicity and innovation can bounce off each other under firm direction. The anime might have ended with one of the more emotionally charged climaxes this season, but it didn’t come as wholly unexpected, given the flow of the series. Reconciliation of the group was the ultimate goal, despite the obvious the series reframed from becoming sloppy or derived, and managed to pull of a touching and exceptional finale. Excellent series and highly recommended.


Rating: 8.5/10

Saturday, 16 April 2011

Level E - Review


Level E outlines a straight-forward sci-fi premise, one we’re certainly all familiar with, not only do aliens exist but Earth is infested with them. As the announcer clarifies at the beginning of each episode, some species come in peace, others not so much, but all in all the Earthlings remain blissfully unaware even as the word DEATH materializes across the planet. Yet despite the ominous opening, Level E is anything but dark-hearted. First and foremost, Level E is a comedy and a bloody brilliant one at that. It gleefully indulges in the weird and wacky while simultaneously delivering a masterpiece of intrigue and originality.

The series is divided into a collection of two-part, three-part episodes, roughly connected by its main character, the trickster Prince as he moves onto his next unsuspecting target. The initial arc is the longest but overall definitely the best. Not only does it introduce the backdrop for the series, the small secluded alien ridden town, it also initiates the first major plot twist – that of Prince Baka’s true identity and his sadistic-prankster personality. The characterization on Level E is generally superb all round, but obviously the Prince stands out and not simply due to the ample amount of screen time. The chemistry between the Prince and the rest of the cast is outstanding, considering that a lot of the humour is derived from interactions and dialogue, particularly in the first episode which is no small feat.

Perhaps the greatest strength of Level E is that is does not just rely on humour to move from point A to point B, there is also a well constructed background of drama on par with any mystery/suspense anime. Level E strives to keep the audience on their toes as such there is always another hidden element to each storyline, another twist, another turn and very often flipping the entire plot on its head with plenty of unexpected endings. I wouldn’t advise trying to figure them out ahead of time. Odds are you’d be wrong. Interestingly the manga was written in 1995-7 and yet manages to parody clichés that continue to plague modern manga and anime – love at first sight, walking in on the opposite sex while showering, etc, whilst openly refusing to resorting to fanservice to get a giggle. Overall the direction is incredibly fresh taking into account its age.

Nevertheless once the preliminary storyline concludes and the series begins to branch off, it never quite returns to same calibre. The next major plot involves five preteens being forced into colour coordinated parody rangers, entertaining but not as good. The same is true for every following episode until the original cast reunite for the finale which quite neatly closes the show with the Prince finally being outsmarted. Unfortunately this is where the manga also ends, so if a second season were on the cards it would be pure adaptation. To be honest, I like this show as is. It doesn’t need a sequel.

I could honestly kick myself for my hesitation towards picking up Level E, alongside Hourou Musuko and Madoka Magica, Level E is one of the better shows this winter season. Highly recommended.

Rating: 9/10


Saturday, 2 April 2011

Hourou Musuko Review

Typically transgender anime characters are stereotyped as flamboyant, usually for comedic effect and in many cases blurring the line with homosexuality – think Grell Sutcliff (Kuroshitsuji). Few take it upon themselves to be serious and to address the issue of growing up in the wrong body with a degree of understanding and maturity. This is what makes Wandering Son magnificent. It explores transsexuality with such remarkable sensitivity and progression in an altogether realistic environment.

The show focused mainly on the dilemma of the male protagonist, Nitori Shuichi, through has two female cross-dressers (Chizuru Sarashina and Yoshino Takatsuki) as well. This dramatically demonstrates the blatant inequality in our modern patriarchal society, in that it is acceptable for females to wear male uniform to a public school without reprimand, however when reversed, a male student wearing a convincing sailor uniform has their parents called in immediately. Nitori even mentions the unfairness that only he was taken out of the school. And only he receives the ‘gay’ tag.

Which brings me onto another thing I admire, Wandering Son, very neatly separates transsexuality from homosexuality. The anime begins midway through the manga, leaving the cast to allude to prior events including a love triangle between Nitori, Takatsuki and another girl, Saori Chiba, which has led to friction between the two girls on the part of the rejected Chiba. In addition Nitori develops feelings for his sister’s friend, Anna, of whom he dates for a while. The romance element is genuinely touching, at the same time relationships are portrayed as complicated and messy, with friendships strained and individuals resentful. Isn’t this just a part of growing up? Needless to say, this is an authentic representation of the bitter truths adolescents face.

Wandering Son is a very slow paced show, even for only eleven episodes. However none manage to become needlessly padded. The storytelling flows from start to finish evenly with absolutely no hick ups. This is planning and writing at its finest. It’s convincing, complex and subtle. On the other hand, the animation is a different issue. At first I found it very creative and detailed, but after the series ended, I wasn’t as fond of it. I guess I just don’t care for the aesthetic, it felt a bit wishy-washy to me but I’m sure that just a personal preference.

In all, Wandering Son is nothing short of excellent. Highly recommended.

Rating: 9/10