As
mentioned prior, it’s the premise that is the shows ultimate chink in its armour.
Moe-detective and generic-male assistant solve crimes! Oh and the moe-detective
has an English name. And she’s supposed to be super adorable but it translates
as arrogant and annoying. And the male is bland. And he has a love interest.
Who is also bland. It’s insipid and it’s been done to death! Comparing this
momentarily with its more recent predecessor Gosick, on the surface neither
anime has differs substantially in terms of concept. But whereas Gosick puts
very little thought into its individual mysteries, or developing the
relationship between the two protagonists, instead opting to be entertaining as
oppose to thought-provoking. Kamisama no Memochou takes the same premise and actually
turns it into something good. And the title makes more sense than ‘Gosick’.
The
series complies several murder mysteries (and a baseball game) into 12
episodes. The length of each mystery varies between two to four episodes. Each
one is beautifully written and delivered, with an unexpected amount of
substance attached. Perhaps the most heart-wrenchingly touching is the final story
arc, since it centres on the attempted suicide of a pivotal cast member. And it
doesn’t get an easy wrap-up. None of the mysteries do because some moments in life
are just that complicated and joyless. And solving the mystery doesn’t change
the course of events, ultimately it doesn’t rewrite the wrong. There are no
easy answers and Kamisama no Memochou does an excellent job of phoning that in.
In that, it is a thoroughly satisfying work of art.
Protagonists
Narumi Fujishima and Alice are stereotypical sure, but not so rigid. Narumi is
not the typical saintly male lead as often is portrayed. Naïve yes, but also
all too human in some places, in particular the final storyline which deals a
fair amount of crap his way. Alice probably gets the rawest deal as her
character never truly grows. Still, she never crosses over to full on annoying
and her powers of deduction remain consistent. She is smart but not omniscient.
The remaining supporting cast do an outstanding job of being both contrived and
interesting. They tend not to play on their stereotypes, offering layers and
more dynamicity. Interestingly, while the cast as a whole is more subdued, they
don’t come across as dull or one-dimensional. They come across as real people.
In
all, Kamisama no Memochou is refreshing. It’s intelligently written and
executed, the characters are well-rounded and likeable, and it is capable of
producing genuine emotion (especially during the final storyline). It’s a pity
that the show only made 12 episodes…
Rating:
8/10
No comments:
Post a Comment