Sunday, 15 July 2012
Blood C - Review
Tuesday, 10 April 2012
Deadman Wonderland - Review

My first anime review of 2012 and it’s something that’s been on the backburner for quite a while. Deadman Wonderland is on the meh side of okay, despite being one of the few anime’s I’ve actually managed to finish since returning to the bustling university lifestyle. I chalk that up to the crisp animation more than the storyline, which I’ve had the most problems with.
Primarily Deadman Wonderland makes no sense. The story is inconsistent, its chief aim is to take the protagonist Ganta, a fourteen year old high school student out of the comfortable life his lead so far and screw around with him as much as possible. For instance, we are initially plummeted into a horrendous mass murder in which Ganta is the number one suspect. How do the authorities reach such a conclusion? He was the only living survivor. Yup, that’s it. I mean they don’t even wait for him to regain consciousness and give his sole survivor eye-witness account before putting him in handcuffs and charging him. Sloppy police work or part of a larger conspiracy? We don’t know because it’s never addressed. Nor is the fact that the warden of the super prison is moonlighting as Ganta’s lawyer; now surely that’s a conflict of interest? Or maybe the warden is in on the conspiracy? Nope, never addressed. Once Ganta is in the prison and this plot point has done its job, off it goes, never to be seen or heard from again.
Instead we’re introduced to Deadman Wonderland a prison/theme park/battle royale game. Complete with poisoners collars that kill off the prison population unless they eat the antidote (candy) every three days. Admittedly this is an interesting twist, because it gives the prisoners a reason to partake in dangerous sports, it’s quite literally a matter of life or death. But does the prison have a never ending supply of generically ‘bad’ criminals who are expendable? Surely this raises eyebrows? Nope, since the spectators think its fake, no one seems to question the body count. Convenient since it won’t be addressed again.
Half way through, the story takes its final leap into disbelief when Ganta discovers a secret prison underneath his own. One where people (like him) with special blood killing powers are pitted against each other semi-mortal kombat style, all the while shadowy agents watch. This just raises even more questions than it answers. Why do they have these powers? Why were they caught if they could clearly use they own blood as a weapon? Perhaps more importantly, can’t we think of better things to do with them rather than cage fight? Nope, not gonna answer these either.
Undeniably the latter half is the most exciting and feels the most organic, in that this is where the plot wanted Ganta originally. But it could have moved along much better and cleaner, instead of being wishy-washy. Unfortunately the series is only 12 episodes long and I have a feeling that many of the unanswered questions would have been brought up later in the show. Too bad there isn’t a season two in sight.
Rating: 6/10
Tuesday, 24 May 2011
Deadman Wonderland 06 – Hummingbird
We’re now half way through Deadman Wonderland and I have a sneaky suspicion that the series is going to be too short. Perhaps a good thing, perhaps not, only time will tell. In light of reaching the middle, Deadman Wonderland takes a break from physically tormenting its protagonist and opts for psychological abuse in the form of a pretty face, Takumi Minatsuki, the sister of Yoh.
However as events quickly transgress, Minatsuki is a little more then a moe character, she is a stark raving mad psychopath. The whole helpless female, abused by her father was a complete act, one that even fooled her brother for a time being. Nevertheless this particular storyline did have similar issues to that of Ganta own conviction. If Yoh thought he was guilty why didn’t he confess? Surely Minatsuki could have played the self-defence/daddy was abusive card? And again, who is it exactly that is placing children on death row? In short the justice system is pretty much a joke.
Verdict: Great
Tuesday, 17 May 2011
Deadman Wonderland 04 & 05
The pieces are steadily starting to fall into place. We learn that Ganta’s imprisonment was indeed a conspiracy perpetrated by the promoter (duh), and we also have an explanation, through somewhat vague. The red man choose to let Ganta live and this prompted the high-ups to target him.
Carnival of Corpses triumphed. This is probably the best episode of the series so far. It was nice to see that the producers pointed out the flawed logic of fighting with blood and did not give their characters an endless supply. Fantastic job all round.
Potential spoiler: I think Shiro is the Red Man
Verdict: Great
Tuesday, 3 May 2011
Deadman Wonderland 03 – G Sector
Once more we witness attempts to shoehorn Ganta into a serial killer, again despite no evidence and this time plenty of eyewitnesses to confirm the existence of the red man. Surely this must prove Ganta is innocent? Not according to Makino at any rate. She concludes that Ganta is the culprit - presumably because he was there and therefore must have a weapon concealed inside his body. You’ve got to admire wrong reasoning yet correct answer. So she locks down the prison and sends a robot after him. As you do.
Another twist is revealed, Deadman Wonderland is a prison inside of a prison inside of a theme park. In fairness looking for a needle in a bunch of needles is more difficult than a haystack, it’s actually quite clever. Verified by Makino complete unawareness, presumably she has no knowledge of the wretched egg/mother goose system either. Takami is clearly playing games with everyone.
Verdict: Great
Wednesday, 27 April 2011
Deadman Wonderland 02 – Antidote (Candy)
The endless supply of filler convicts aside, we’re introduced to our first criminal villain, a standard hot-headed thug, nothing more, nothing less. Considering this is a maximum security prison, one that goes that extra mile to deny basic human rights, I was under the impression you had to be convicted of a substantial offence, say massacring your classmates. Where are the real psychopaths? The really dangerous folk, not just the thugs! Please bring them out soon!
Ganta continues to darn his helpless-innocent cloak even in the face of his new brutal surroundings. He remains blissfully unaware of the rules, for example the importance of eating the prison candy/antidote, as well as befriended Takami. Again this is prison, it’s full of dangerous people, people who might appear outwardly friendly and charming but whom are secretly manipulative. Its not that complicated, but then Ganta is a naïve child. And of course since Ganta is innocent, presumably it is possible that other convicts have also been falsely convicted.
Verdict: Very Good.
Friday, 11 March 2011
Umineko no Naku Koro ni Review

Umineko no Naku Koro ni (When the Seagulls cry) is considered to be the third in the When They Cry series, through notably different from the previous two Higurashi No Naku Koro ni instalments. Whereas Higurashi is a truly marvellous feat of horror/suspense animation, with its genuinely innovative formula and gory atmosphere, Umineko in comparison is a slight let down. It tries to hard to heave the same twists and turns of its predecessor, thus overcomplicating the story unnecessarily. Towards the end it reaches the point where anything could be introduced into plot and the characters would just accept it, hiding behind the excuse “a wizard did it/it was just an illusion”.
The initial concept is perhaps more compelling then Higurashi. The wealthy Ushiromiya family gather on the isolated
This adds an extra dimension to the anime, but it also makes Umineko feel cluttered. As the arcs continue, more witches and their familiars are introduced, and the murders become more fantastical. On top of that every character has been dead at least once to disprove that the killer is amongst the Ushiromiya family. It becomes increasingly difficult to accept a rational explanation other then, the characters are on mushrooms or Battler has an overactive imagination. To be honest, Battler as the killer would be a good final twist, but the anime seems to leaning so far into the realms of fantasy that anything other then magic would seem to be a cop out.
The characters act as a lifesaver. Battler works well as the male protagonist, mainly prompted through skepticism rather then a superior intellect, thus allowing his frustration to feel believable. Beatrice swings back and forth from cold, maniacally laughing villain to disinterested and aloof opponent. It seems Battler acknowledging her is more important than winning (killing everyone, which she managed to do in the very first arc). The George/Shannon romance is feels slightly more plausible then the Jessica/Kanon romance, but that might be because it was introduced first and the likelihood of two cousins falling for two servant siblings seems far fetched. The adults are multi layered and complex, the arcs allow for a rich exploration of the Ushiromiya family life and background that enable the aunts and uncles to develop beyond the greedy money grabbing bunch portrayed in the first episode. The only annoying character is Maria, partly because no one seems to take notice of her psycho mood swings.
In all, irredeemably mind bogglingly and thought-provoking, satisfactory execution with a strong direction, but ultimately woefully inconclusive. The show ends on a cliff hanger that almost renders the entire anime pointless if there isn't going to be a somewhat stable wrap up. At the moment Umineko ranks a respectable 7/10, chiefly because there is no sequel, leaving the show feeling uneven. It seems I have another anime to add to my fingers crossed list.
Rating: 7/10
Monday, 3 January 2011
Shiki - Review

Tuesday, 21 December 2010
High School of the Dead [Complete]

Zombies, carnage, teenagers, boobs. Seems uncomplicated enough. The plot reads like a typical zombie flick, one moment everything is peachy, the next a seemingly normal high school is a zombie feeding ground. Pretty much wiping out all unnamed characters in one frenzy. The survivors; five students and one airhead nurse decide to band together and flee the school. Fortunately after the initial shock of zombie apocalypse now, our heroes become very insightful, handling their current predicament oddly clinical for teenagers, factor in their suddenly useful talents - gun okatu and Kendo champion, and its no wonder these kids are able to survive 12 episodes while their classmates get gobbled alive.
In all, it could have been an enjoyable show, were it not spoiled by the obligatory panties shot, lowering the tone for no other reason then because it could. All right, the creators were trying to push the violence, gore and sex boundaries, but most of the time, the fanservice department was so outrageous that it just became silly. Every Japanese girl having a pair of double D's water balloons strapped across her chest, while running around in grossly inappropriate attire for a zombie apocalypse, might be the average 14 year old male's wet dream, but as a woman, I found myself excluded from liking otherwise flawless action sequences due to sheer embarrassment.
So, what made me stick this show out until the end? Kohta Hirano. The chubby, adorable, resident gun enthusiast, probably the only character who doesn't want the world to go back to normal and have to go back to being no one. The sanest response to zombies, I suppose.

















